This blog was prompted by comments from Mindframes and Survivor on the blog by Mano related to the recent marathon. Mindframes states that "the real value can only be perceived by a runner". Survivor counters "any one can understand shaving off time...need not be runners alone". This stream of conversation is interesting because there seems to be some tension (in the sense that each statement has its merits) between the arguments.
I found this stream of thought very interesting. For instance there is lot of talk about professor's sitting in the ivory tower and creating theories out of thin air without ever having any work experience in the "real" world. Hmm...Now lets think about this. Imagine you are a biologist working with say Apes. Is it a requirement that you live like or socialize with an Ape to get an understanding about its behavior?
Surely no! I agree that it is difficult to have any understanding about the animal if you have never been closer than 100 feet to an Ape. But if we have observational data say collected by a zoo keeper, we can always run a few regressions and claim that here are some empirical regularities. Hence, not living or being near the ape does not mean one cannot draw valid inferences but the real question is does this suffice? Not really! Data can only tell you as much. The critical aspect is, sometimes what we miss is intuition and feel for the problem on hand. This leads to to mechanical use of tools which may or may not be relevant. The only solution in my view is that it is essential to mingle once in a while with the Ape to get a feel for what it really is. Essentially this is what biologists tend to do (or so I believe).
In that context, there is merit in both arguments.
Thursday, November 15, 2007
I cant think of a title
Posted by Mad Max at 4:58 PM 2 comments
Wednesday, November 14, 2007
Is it just Meat?
I have always been a believer in mind over matter. But, when people suggest that you can control your body, where do you draw the line? How do you define "you" and "your body" ? I am not talking about souls etc...which is more spiritual.
We all believe that the love of a mother is full of feelings which surpasses most of the other categories of love. For some lizards, where the neocortex is not fully developed, the young ones have to start defending themselves from birth for fear of cannibalism .Yes, their mothers can eat them. For humans, these are very well developed as we are supposedly somewhere in the top of the evolution chain,and so we can feel these emotions. Now, what was mind again? If we did not have a well developed brain, we may not have any emotions after all.
Taking it one step further, there is a region of the brain called the Amygdala , which stores memories of the emotional events occuring in our life. If you think you can never forget what someone did to you, blame it on the amygdala. Sometimes, amygdala can even hijack your neo cortex ( the thinking part)and make you too emotional.
If you think - Brain
If you walk,talk (motor control) - Brain ( neocortex)
If you feel - Brain (amygdala)
If you cry - Brain (amygdala)
If you feel like writing a blog - (amygdala) (For Mindframes, this function is stored as a memory in the amygdala :-)
If you love - Brain
If you feel paranoid - blame it on a parasite
** Recent research suggests that parasites, in particular toxoplasma, form cysts in the brain, often taking up residence in the amygdala. This may provide clues as to how specific parasites manipulate behavior and may contribute to the development of disorders, including paranoia.**
Coming back to my original question, what am I controlling ? My brain seems to be doing everything....So, do I categorize my brain as "I" or "Part of My Body" . To me, everything finally seems to be just meat. And my mind seems related to how well my brain has developed.!!!!
Posted by Survivor at 5:13 PM 4 comments
Thursday, November 08, 2007
Happy Diwali!
The legend goes that Diwali is celebrated to honour the return of Rama with his wife Sita (after vanquishing Ravana) to Ayodhya. The legend also states that Rama after vanquishing Ravana refused to take Sita back as his wife, and she was upset and cleansed herself in fire, emerging unscathed to prove she was pure. Evidently when they got back to Ayodhya, they weren't on the best of the terms. We celebrate Diwali anyway.
Another legend goes that Sita gave birth to 2 sons Lava and Kusha, and something happened in the form of a row, and Mother Earth swallowed Sita yet again.
As a human race, we never tend to speak evil of the dead. I can well imagine how Rama became Lord Rama over time, giving us yet another excuse to eat and make merry.
Well ... I don't know how or when Diwali celebrationa started. I do know that it was one of my favourite festivals. I grew up in a residential school, and most holidays were not declared holidays in our school. Diwali was. (Well...what would you do with 750 children on campus if there were declared holidays for Mahaveer Jayanthi etc? ) It was also one of the opportunities to wear new clothes, and attend the Diwali puja in School. 10th and 12th grade students wore sarees and dhotis, and I can't tell you how wonderful the whole scene looked.
Diwali is here again. Celebrations have been pushed to the week-end for those of us who don't have declared holidays on Diwali.
Happy Diwali Folks!
Posted by nourish-n-cherish at 2:41 PM 8 comments
San Jose Rock 'n' Roll Half Marathon- The best party this side of town
Summer this year, I ran my longest training run for the San Fran marathon, the day before my son was born. I ran the second longest training run the week after we all came home from the hospital. Yes, it was a heady time and I had lots of fun running and completing the San Francisco Marathon on June 29th. Most importantly, I ran and completed sans injury- a record breaking first. Efforts at researching biomechanics were paying off finally. As a matter of fact, I ran almost 10 miles the week after the marathon. Compared to weeks of no walking after my prior marathons, this was definitely a big win and I was euphoric. I had to up the ante.
Labels: Running
Posted by Manohar at 11:21 AM 10 comments
Wednesday, November 07, 2007
Circle of life
Me-t-1: I love Rajini movies. I whistle because it is fun and people around me are whistling too. Awesome thalaivar
Me-t0: How shameless this whole tamil movie industry is? Some oldie is running around the tree with girl.
Look at Hollywood, they are awesome, Reasonable.
Me-t+1: Hey what is not to like about Rajini movies? It is cult classic in the same mould as star wars. Why should
entertainment be intellectual? Hollywood is just a glorified Bollywood
This is just one of the thought processes. Almost every aspect of life my thoughts go through this cycle. Accepting something at one level and going to other end (or different view point) and swinging back to the old view point OR aligning with the old view point with different rationalization.
Another good example is cultural values (esp. Indian values). Treating Indian values as the greatest thing long back (and bashing "floating" American values) and standing by American individualistic values for a period of time and rethinking whether family ties (group) may be better for my way of life etc.
With every transition back to older (almost opposite) view point, even with proper rationalization, it feels like a hypo critic thing to do. But still I do it.
May be maturing is nothing but finding this multi layer nature of life!
Labels: Life Philosophical Thought
Posted by nourish-n-cherish at 3:33 PM 9 comments